Establishment of dairy product risk rank model based on the perspective of time, space, and potential contaminants

Main Article Content

Shengmei Liao
Kang Hu
Su Xu
Guangcan Tao
Qinghai Zhang

Keywords

dairy products, hazardous substances, risk classification, spatial-temporal distribution characteristics

Abstract

China ranks third in the global production of dairy products; however, dairy products are extremely vulnerable to contamination, which leaves harmful effects on the human body. This study assesses the risk classification of hazards, and examines regional and temporal distribution patterns using sample data on dairy products produced in China from 2017 to 2021. The risk value was estimated using the entropy weight method. Both global and local spatial autocorrelations were applied. The findings indicate that the primary high and relatively high-risk substances in circulation and production are veterinary medications, additives, microorganisms, and chromium whereas the main high and relatively high-risk substances in catering are additives, microorganisms, and chromium. Unqualified dairy samples were reported from 2017 to 2021. The categorical sampling of dairy products primarily takes place in western China, and only coliform group and total bacterial counts demonstrated high–high and low–low agglomeration, respectively. The dynamic adjustment of targeted regulatory opinions and regulatory plans is proposed to provide scientific basis for the safe supervision of dairy products through the classification of risk substances and the characteristics of related time and space distribution.

Abstract 597 | PDF Downloads 450 HTML Downloads 0 XML Downloads 17

References

Abd El-Salam, M.M., Farahat, M.F., Abu-Zuid, G.I. and Saad, S.G. 2017. Application of in-plant control measures in some Egyptian micro-scale dairy enterprises and its impact on heavy metal contents of their products. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 189(10): 486. 10.1007/s10661-017-6214-x

Agrimonti, C., Bottari, B., Sardaro, M.L.S. and Marmiroli, N. 2019. Application of real-time PCR (qPCR) for characterization of microbial populations and type of milk in dairy food products. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition 59(3): 423–442. 10.1080/10408398.2017.1375893

Akinyemi, M.O., Ayeni, K.I., Ogunremi, O.R., Adeleke, R.A., Oguntoyinbo, F.A., Warth, B. and Ezekiel, C.N. 2021. A review of microbes and chemical contaminants in dairy products in sub-Saharan Africa. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety 20(2): 1188–1220. 10.1111/1541-4337.12712

Aktar, S., Sarker, Y.A., Sachi, S., Ferdous, J., Al Noman, Z., Mohiuddin, K.M. and Sikder, M.H. 2020. Environmental contamination of lead in dairy farms in Narayangonj, Bangladesh. Journal of Advanced Veterinary and Animal Research 7(4): 621–625. 10.5455/javar.2020.g460

Álvarez-Días, F., Torres-Parga, B., Valdivia-Flores, A.G., Quezada-Tristán, T., Alejos-De La Fuente, J.I., Sosa-Ramírez, J. and Rangel-Muñoz, E.J. 2022. Aspergillus flavus and total aflatoxins occurrence in dairy feed and aflatoxin M1 in bovine milk in Aguascalientes, Mexico. Toxins 14(5): 292. 10.3390/toxins14050292

Asosega, K.A., Adebanji, A.O. and Abdul, I.W. 2021. Spatial analysis of the prevalence of obesity and overweight among women in Ghana. BMJ Open 11(1): e041659. 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041659

Bommuraj, V., Chen, Y., Gal, O., Ben Ari, J., Kertsnus-Banchik, E., Barel, S. and Shimshoni, J.A. 2020. Human pharmaceutical and pesticide residues in Israeli dairy milk in association with dietary risk assessment. Food Additives & Contaminants Part B-Surveillance 13(4): 233–243. 10.1080/19393210.2020.1764114

Benjamin Harvey, H. and Sotardi, S.T. 2018. The Pareto Principle. Journal of the American College of Radiology 15: 931. 10.1016/j.jacr.2018.02.026

Caggianob, B.A.A.R., Macchiatoc, M., Paolod, C., Ragostae, M., Painof, S., Cortesia, M.L. 2006. Heavy metal concentrations in dairy products from sheep milk collected in two regions of southern Italy. Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica 47: 69–73. 10.1186/1751-0147-47-69

Cai, S.D. and Zhao, W.X. 2017. Study on microbial contamination of dairy and the prevention measures. Beverage Industry 20(2): 71–73. 10.3969/j.issn.1007-7871.2017.02.024

Chen, Y., Ji, H., Chen, L.J., Jiang, R. and Wu, Y.N. 2018. Food safety knowledge, attitudes and behavior among dairy plant workers in Beijing, northern China. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 15(1): 63. 10.3390/ijerph15010063

Chen, H., Ma, S.J. and Yuan, Y.F. 2020. Dairy products safety supervision risks and effective governance system optimization in China’s megalopolises in the new era. Journal of Dairy Science and Technology 43(6): 51–57. 10.15922/j.cnki.jdst.2020.06.010

Chen, Q., Meng, M., Li, W., Xiong, Y., Fang, Y. and Lin, Q. 2023. Emerging biosensors to detect aflatoxin M(1) in milk and dairy products. Food Chemistry 398: 133848. 10.1016/j.foodchem.2022.133848

Cheng, X.P. and Pang, S.L. 2016. Research on spatial-temporal characteristics and changing trend of China's dairy industry geographic agglomeration. China Dairy Industry 44(4): 38–41. 10.3969/j.issn.1001-2230.2016.04.010

Cummins, C., Berry, D.P., Murphy, J.P., Lorenz, I. and Kennedy, E. 2017. The effect of colostrum storage conditions on dairy heifer calf serum immunoglobulin G concentration and preweaning health and growth rate. Journal of Dairy Science 100(1): 525–535. 10.3168/jds.2016-10892

Cunha-Zeri, G., Guidolini, J.F., Branco, E.A. and Ometto, J.P. 2022. How sustainable is the nitrogen management in Brazil? A sustainability assessment using the entropy weight method. Journal of Environmental Management 316: 115330. 10.1016/j.jenvman.2022.115330

Elmoslemany, A.M., Keefe, G.P., Dohoo, I.R. and Jayarao, B.M. 2009. Risk factors for bacteriological quality of bulk tank milk in Prince Edward Island dairy herds. Part 1: overall risk factors. Journal of Dairy Science 92(6): 2634–2643. 10.3168/jds.2008-1812

Feil, A.A., Schreiber, D., Haetinger, C., Haberkamp, A.M., Kist, J.I., Rempel, C. and da Silva, G.R. 2020. Sustainability in the dairy industry: a systematic literature review. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 27(27): 33527–33542. 10.1007/s11356-020-09316-9

Garnier, L., Valence, F. and Mounier, J. 2017. Diversity and control of spoilage fungi in dairy products: an update. Microorganisms 5(3): 42. 10.3390/microorganisms5030042

Ge, W.P., Yang, X.J., Wu, X.Y., Wang, Z., Geng, W. and Guo, C.F. 2016. Phthalate residue in goat milk-based infant formulas manufactured in China. Journal of Dairy Science 99(10): 7776–7781. 10.3168/jds.2016-11061

Guo, L., Xu, W., Li, C., Guo, Y., Yamei and Chagan, I. 2021. Comparative study of physicochemical composition and microbial community of Khoormog, Chigee, and Airag, traditionally fermented dairy products from Xilin Gol in China. Food Science & Nutrition 9(3): 1564–1573. 10.1002/fsn3.2131

Gurudatt, N.G., Lee, K., Heo, W. and Jung, H.I. 2022. Simple ultrasensitive electrochemical detection of the DBP plasticizer for the risk assessment of South Korean river waters. Analyst 147(15): 3525–3533. 10.1039/d2an00809b

Hu, G.G., Liu, J., Wang, Y.H., Yang, Z.N. and Shao, H.B. 2022. Applications of plant protein in the dairy industry. Foods 11(8): 1067. 10.3390/foods11081067

Iyer, M., Anand, U., Thiruvenkataswamy, S., Winster, H., Narayanasamy, A., Prajapati, V.K., Tiwari, C.K., Gopalakrishnan, A.V., Bontempi, E., Sonne, C., Barceló, D. and Vellingiri, B. 2023. A review of chromium (Cr) epigenetic toxicity and health hazards. Science of the Total Environment 882: 163483. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2023.163483

Jindal, P., Bedi, J., Singh, R. and Gill, J.P. 2021. Epidemiological assessment of antibiotic residues in dairy farm milk and farm waste and water in northern India. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 28(23): 29455–29466. 10.1007/s11356-020-12057-4

Liu, G., Bi, R., Wang, S., Li, F. and Guo, G. 2013. The use of spatial autocorrelation analysis to identify PAHs pollution hotspots at an industrially contaminated site. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 185(11): 9549–9558. 10.1007/s10661-013-3272-6

Li, L.J., Ma, Y.H. and Lu, M.H. 2016a. Pollution and control of microorganisms and toxins in dairy products processing. Shaanxi Journal of Agricultural Sciences 65(5): 72–75. CNKI:SUN:SNKX.0.2016-05-023

Li, J., Xu, Y., Wang, L. and Li, F. 2019. Heavy metal occurrence and risk assessment in dairy feeds and manures from the typical intensive dairy farms in China. Environmental Science and Pollution Research 26(7): 6348–6358. 10.1007/s11356-019-04125-1

Li, Z., Xue, F., Xu, L., Peng, C., Kuang, H., Ding, T., Xu, C., Sheng, C., Gong, Y. and Wang, L. 2011. Simultaneous determination of nine types of phthalate residues in commercial milk products using HPLC-ESI-MS-MS. Journal of Chromatographic Science 49(4): 338–43. 10.1093/chrsci/49.4.337

Li, S.Q., Zhao, Z., Liu, L.J., Yue, H., Li, C.Z. and Shao, J.B. 2016b. Detection of 7 additives in dairy products by high performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Dairy Science and Technology 39(4): 22–25. 10.15922/j.cnki.jdst.2016.04.005

Martin, N.H., Trmcic, A., Hsieh, T.H., Boor, K.J. and Wiedmann, M. 2016. The evolving role of coliforms as indicators of unhygienic processing conditions in dairy foods. Frontiers in Microbiology 7: 1549. 10.3389/fmicb.2016.01549

Molognoni, L., de Sá Ploêncio, L.A., Valese, A.C., Lindner, J.D.D. and Daguer, H. 2016. A simple and fast method for the inspection of preservatives in cheeses and cream by liquid chromatography electrospray-tandem mass spectrometry. Talanta 147: 370–382. 10.1016/j.talanta.2015.10.008

Nastasescu, V., Mititelu, M., Goumenou, M., Docea, A.O., Renieri, E., Udeanu, D.I. and Ghica, M. 2020. Heavy metal and pesticide levels in dairy products: evaluation of human health risk. Food and Chemical Toxicology 146: 111844. 10.1016/j.fct.2020.111844

Nishimwe, K., Bowers, E.L., de Dieu Ayabagabo, J., Habimana, R., Mutiga, S. and Maier, D.E. 2022. Preliminary sampling of aflatoxin M1 contamination in raw milk from dairy farms using feed ingredients from Rwanda. Mycotoxin Research 38(2): 107–115. 10.1007/s12550-022-00454-2

Qu, X.Y., Zheng, N., Zhou, X.W., Li, S.L., Wang, J.Q. and Zhang, W.J. 2018. Analysis and risk assessment of seven toxic element residues in raw bovine milk in China. Biological Trace Element Research 183(1): 92–101. 10.1007/s12011-017-1116-x

Rajala-Schultz, P., Nodtvedt, A., Halasa, T. and Persson Waller, K. 2021. Prudent use of antibiotics in dairy cows: the nordic approach to udder health. Frontiers in Veterinary Science 8: 623998. 10.3389/fvets.2021.623998

Schopf, M.F., Pierezan, M.D., Rocha, R., Pimentel, T.C., Esmerino, E.A., Marsico, E.T. and Verruck, S. 2022. Pesticide residues in milk and dairy products: an overview of processing degradation and trends in mitigating approaches. Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition xxx: 1–15. 10.1080/10408398.2022.2103642

Slosarkova, S., Pechova, A., Stanek, S., Fleischer, P., Zouharova, M. and Nejedla, E. 2021. Microbial contamination of harvested colostrum on Czech dairy farms. Journal of Dairy Science 104(10): 11047–11058. 10.3168/jds.2020-19949

Stobnicka-Kupiec, A., Golofit-Szymczak, M. and Gorny, R. 2019. Microbial contamination level and microbial diversity of occupational environment in commercial and traditional dairy plants. Annals of Agricultural and Environmental Medicine 26(4): 555–565. 10.26444/aaem/112381

Su, C., Gao, Y., Qu, X., Zhou, X., Yang, X., Huang, S., Han, L., Zheng, N. and Wang, J. 2021. The occurrence, pathways, and risk assessment of heavy metals in raw milk from industrial areas in China. Toxics 9(12): 320. 10.3390/toxics9120320

Taghizadeh, S.F., Rezaee, R., Davarynejad, G., Asili, J., Nemati, S.H., Goumenou, M. and Karimi, G. 2018. Risk assessment of exposure to aflatoxin B1 and ochratoxin A through consumption of different Pistachio (Pistacia vera L.) cultivars collected from four geographical regions of Iran. Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology 61: 61–66. 10.1016/j.etap.2018.05.010

Tfouni, S.A.V. and Toledo, M.C.F. 2002. Determination of benzoic and sorbic acids in Brazilian food. Food Control 13(2): 117–123. 10.1016/S0956-7135(01)00084-6

van Asselt, E.D., van der Fels-Klerx, H.J., Marvin, H.J.P., van Bokhorst-van de Veen, H. and Groot, M.N. 2017. Overview of food safety hazards in the European dairy supply chain. Comprehensive Reviews in Food Science and Food Safety, 16(1): 59–75. 10.1111/1541-4337.12245

van Kessel, J.S., Karns, J.S., Gorski, L., MCluskey, B.J. and Perdue, M.L. 2004. Prevalence of Salmonellae, Listeria monocytogenes, and fecal coliforms in bulk tank milk on US dairies. Journal of Dairy Science 87(9): 2822–2830. 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(04)73410-4

Wang, W., Liu, Y.N., Yin, P., Wang, L.J., Liu, J.M., Qi, J.L. and Zhou, M.G. 2021a. Influences of using different spatial weight matrices in analyzing spatial autocorrelation of cardiovascular diseases mortality in China. Zhonghua Liu Xing Bing Xue Za Zhi 42(8): 1437–1444. 10.3760/cma.j.cn112338-20201102-01293

Wang, Z., van der Fels-Klerx, H.J. and Lansink, A. 2020. Optimization of sampling for monitoring chemicals in the food supply chain using a risk-based approach: the case of aflatoxins and dioxins in the Dutch dairy chain. Risk Analysis 40(12): 2539–2560. 10.1111/risa.13605

Wang, Z., van der Fels-Klerx, H.J. and Oude Lansink, A. 2021b. Modeling cost-effective monitoring schemes for food safety contaminants: case study for dioxins in the dairy supply chain. Food Research International 141: 110110. 10.1016/j.foodres.2021.110110

Wang, L., Zhang, P. and Liu, F. 2018. New Australia dairy safety supervision mechanism research and experience reference. World Agriculture (8): 160–165. 10.13856/j.cn11-1097/s.2018.08.024

Xu, X., Cheng, X., Zhao, L., Fang, H., Guo, Q., Ju, L., Li, S., Cai, S., Piao, W. and Yu, D. 2022. Consumption of milk and dairy products among junior high and senior high school students–China, 2016–2017. China CDC Weekly 4(3): 47–51. 10.46234/ccdcw2021.271

Xu, Z.Z., Feng, Z.H., Wang, K.W. and Wang, M. 2021. Comparison and prospect of Chinese and international supervision mode of raw milk. Quality and Safety of Agro-Product (1): 73–78.

Yan, M., Niu, C., Li, X., Wang, F., Jiang, S., Li, K. and Yao, Z. 2022. Heavy metal levels in milk and dairy products and health risk assessment: a systematic review of studies in China. Science of the Total Environment 851(1): 158161. 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.158161

Zamani Mazdeh, F., Sasanfar, S., Chalipour, A., Pirhadi, E., Yahyapour, G., Mohammadi, A. and Hajimahmoodi, M. 2017. Simultaneous determination of preservatives in dairy products by HPLC and chemometric analysis. International Journal of Analytical Chemistry 2017: 3084359. 10.1155/2017/3084359

Zhang, Q., Pei, X.Y. and Huang, X.P. 2019. Research progress of contamination and control of moulds and yeasts in fermented milk. Journal of Food Safety and Quality 10(5): 1133–1137. CNKI:SUN:SPAJ.0.2019-05-007

Zhao, S., Lin, H., Li, S., Liu, C., Meng, J., Guan, W. and Liu, B. 2022. Modeling of chilled/supercooled pork storage quality based on the entropy weight method. Animals (Basel) 12(11): 1415. 10.3390/ani12111415

Zhou, L., Yang, Q. and Xu, C.B. 2021. Development degree of dairy products market and food safety regulation in western China. Southwest China Journal of Agricultural Sciences 34(8): 1796–1802. 10.16213/j.cnki.scjas.2021.8.030

Zou, Q., Wang, T., Qu, J. and Zhong, J. 2018. Research on potential hazards risk classification model in Chinese baijiu. Liquor Making 45(2): 35–38. CNKI:SUN:NJZZ.0.2018-02-015

Zuo, Z., Wang, M., Cui, H., Wang, Y., Wu, J., Qi, J. and Xu, A. 2020. Spatiotemporal characteristics and the epidemiology of tuberculosis in China from 2004 to 2017 by the nationwide surveillance system. BMC Public Health 20(1): 1284. 10.1186/s12889-00-09331-y