Assessing the socio-economic dimension of food quality and safety regulations: research challenges and recent advances

Main Article Content

Mario Mazzocchi
Maddalena Ragona
Liana Giorgi
Gerhard Schiefer
Melanie Fritz
Emanuele Novelli
Henrik Krapp
Daniel Spichtinger
Roland Poms

Keywords

better regulation, food safety, impact assessment, MoniQA, socio-economic

Abstract

Introduction Monitoring and Quality Assurance (MoniQA) is a multidisciplinary network of experts aiming at harmonizing worldwide food quality, safety monitoring and control strategies, dealing with socio-economic impact assessment and working for better regulations (Poms et al., 2009). Objectives MoniQA provides support for a systematic assessment of the socio-economic effects of new European food quality and safety regulations. Impact is evaluated in terms of efficiency, effectiveness and consistency of application, and with respect to different stakeholders (consumers, industry, regulatory bodies, etc.). As a result, socio-economic impact assessment will enhance the effectiveness and the efficiency of new food quality and safety regulations. Methods Following the European guidelines for regulatory impact assessment, MoniQA has developed a generic Evaluation Framework, dealing with food safety challenges, such as the costs and benefits of strict control measures targeting the agriculture and food industry, the implications of imposing controls independently on export markets, the costs and benefits of extensive training programmes, and the risks associated with lowering standards and relaxing controls. In parallel, MoniQA is developing a decision support system, which compares the effectiveness of policy implementation at the level of the individual enterprise (micro level) with the success of policies within and across countries (macro level). As there are so many stakeholders (e.g. small versus large enterprises, differences in risk profiles and management structures, sectors and geographic location, etc.), this tool is expected to allow an understanding of the different scenarios and facilitate policy-making at various levels (e.g. regional, national, European Union, etc.). An Evaluation Toolbox, based on the complementarities of the Evaluation Framework and the decision support system, will provide information about: data availability, gaps and quantitative and qualitative collection procedures; a systematic classification of impacts; validated results from the case studies; and up-to-date guidelines on evaluation strategies. Results The expected output of our overall research work is a toolbox (intended as a set of procedures) that can be used by policy makers better to assess the potential impacts of future food quality and safety regulations. This toolbox will provide methodological instruments for qualitative and quantitative assessment in the important policy area of food quality and safety. Conclusion The co-operation being fostered among food scientists and socio-economic scientists within the MoniQA network is essential for applying the procedures for impact assessment that are being explored in the socio-economic research. This is in line with the MoniQA objective to achieve a sustainable network of food quality and safety experts in the long term.

Abstract 24 | PDF Downloads 17

References

European Commission (2000) White Paper on Food Safety. COM(1999) 719 final, Brussels, European Commission.
European Commission (2002a) Communication from the commission on Impact Assessment. COM (2002) 276 final, Brussels, European Commission.
European Commission (2002b) Communication from the commission: Action Plan ‘Simplifying and improving the regulatory Environment’. COM (2002) 278 final, Brussels, European Commission.
European Commission (2005a) Better Regulation for Growth and Jobs in the European Union. COM (2005) 97 final, Brussels, European Commission.
European Commission (2005b) Impact Assessment Guidelines.SEC (2005) 791. Brussels, European Commission.
Fritz M., Schiefer G. (2008) A multi-level cost benefit approach for regulatory decision support in food safety and quality assurance scenarios.Innovation: The European Journal of social science Research,21, 177–182.
Giorgi L., Lindner F. (2009) The contemporary governance of food safety: taking stock and looking ahead. Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops & Foods,1, 36–49.
Mazzocchi M., Capacci S., Ragona M. (2008) Evaluating the economic impact of public intervention on food markets: effects of the 5-a-day campaign on the UK fruit and vegetable sector.Paper presented at the XII Congress of the European Association of Agricultural Economists, 26–29 August 2008, Ghent, Belgium.
Monitoring and Quality Assurance in the Food Supply Chain (MoniQA) (2009a) Contract Number Food-CT-2006-036337Socio-economic impact assessment (WP7). Available at http://www.moniqa.org/socioeconomics
Monitoring and Quality Assurance in the Food Supply Chain (MoniQA) (2009b) Socio-economics of food quality and safety regulations. MoniQA Factsheet No. 4.
Poms R., Thomas M., Finglas P., Astley S., Spichtinger D.,Rose M., Popping B., Alldrick A., Egmond H.v., Solfrizzo M.,Mills C., Kneifel W., Paulin S., Oreopoulou V., Anh To K.,Carcea M., Tureskja H., Saarela M., Haugen J.-E., Gross M.(2009) Monitoring and Quality Assurance (MoniQA ) – anEU-funded Network of Excellence (NoE) working towards the harmonisation of worldwide food quality and safety monitoring and control strategies. Quality Assurance and Safety of Crops & Foods,1, 9–22.
Ragona M., Mazzocchi M. (2008a) Food safety regulation, economic impact assessment and quantitative methods. Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research,21,145–158.
Ragona M., Mazzocchi M. (2008b) Impact evaluation of food safety regulations: A review of quantitative methods. Paper presented at the 110thSeminar of the European Association of Agricultural Economists ‘System Dynamics and Innovation in Food Networks’, 18–22 February 2008, Innsbruck-Igls, Austria.
Ragona M., Mazzocchi M. (2008c) Measuring the impacts of food safety regulations: a methodological review. Paper presented at the XII Congress of the European Association of Agricultural Economists, 26–29 August 2008, Ghent, Belgium.